To celebrate the release of GATK 4.0, we are giving away free credits for running the GATK4 Best Practices pipelines in FireCloud, our secure online analysis portal. It’s first come first serve, so sign up now to claim your free credits worth $250. Sponsored by Google Cloud. Learn more at

UnifiedGenotyper: different -glm values result in different annotated values

tommycarstensentommycarstensen United KingdomMember

I have run UnifiedGenotyper with the -glm options SNP and BOTH. These two approaches yield identical variants and identical genotype likelihoods (at least the first 100k variants I checked). However, a few of the annotations have different values:

-glm SNP on the left and -glm BOTH on the right:

MQRankSum=-1.762 MQRankSum=-1.785

MQRankSum=-5.307 MQRankSum=-4.970

MQRankSum=0.262 MQRankSum=-0.022

MQRankSum=-0.680 MQRankSum=-0.710

MQRankSum=1.016 MQRankSum=0.231

MQRankSum=-0.693 MQRankSum=-0.681

MQRankSum=-0.839 MQRankSum=-0.830

MQRankSum=1.924 MQRankSum=1.889

MQRankSum=-0.991 MQRankSum=-0.665

MQRankSum=-0.459 MQRankSum=-0.958

BaseQRankSum=-1.803 BaseQRankSum=-1.881

BaseQRankSum=6.918 BaseQRankSum=6.894

BaseQRankSum=-2.512 BaseQRankSum=-2.524

BaseQRankSum=2.000 BaseQRankSum=2.020

BaseQRankSum=2.095 BaseQRankSum=2.006

BaseQRankSum=2.134 BaseQRankSum=2.223

BaseQRankSum=-3.622 BaseQRankSum=-3.547

BaseQRankSum=1.569 BaseQRankSum=1.586

BaseQRankSum=-3.416 BaseQRankSum=-3.733

BaseQRankSum=-1.745 BaseQRankSum=-1.769

ReadPosRankSum=-0.341 ReadPosRankSum=-0.280

ReadPosRankSum=4.207 ReadPosRankSum=4.190

ReadPosRankSum=-3.809 ReadPosRankSum=-3.832

ReadPosRankSum=-2.047 ReadPosRankSum=-2.060

ReadPosRankSum=-1.279 ReadPosRankSum=-1.232

ReadPosRankSum=-3.921 ReadPosRankSum=-3.955

ReadPosRankSum=-1.500 ReadPosRankSum=-1.486

ReadPosRankSum=-0.374 ReadPosRankSum=-0.403

ReadPosRankSum=3.209 ReadPosRankSum=3.188

ReadPosRankSum=1.889 ReadPosRankSum=1.868

Why is that?

I noticed another user got different variants, but I get the same variants and the same likelihoods:

I ran single threaded.

I use MQRankSum and ReadPosRankSum for VariantRecalibrator, so it affects my downstream results, if the annotations are -glm dependent. Hence I am asking my question. I hope you can illuminate me. Thank you.

Best Answer


  • tommycarstensentommycarstensen United KingdomMember

    Makes sense. Thank you.

Sign In or Register to comment.